Post new question
Top Student
Posts: 6
Member Since: ‎10-13-2011
Message 1 of 2 (545 Views)

Replacement HD for Seagate ST3750528AS in Pavilion p6204y

The hard drive on my 4-yr old HP-Pavilion p6204y desktop failed the SMART Short Self Test. I'm otherwise happy with the computer and would be happy to keep using it with a new HD.


The original drive is available as well as Seagate's Barracuda ST31000524AS. These two Seagate drives have a lot of bad reviews on Amazon--everything from early failure to poor firmware.


Can the Western Digital 1TB HD WD 10EZEX which has a much better review history be used as a plug-in substitute in my computer? The transfer rate is greater (6 gb/s compared to 3) and storage capacity  (1TB as against 600gb). Are there any adjustments that need to be made if I switch to the WD HD?


I haven't done this type of thing before but the HP instructions look pretty straightforward.


Any suggestions and advice would be appreciated.


Posts: 7,450
Member Since: ‎09-28-2010
Message 2 of 2 (528 Views)

Re: Replacement HD for Seagate ST3750528AS in Pavilion p6204y

The WD will work in your system, at the older Sata2 3GB/s rate. The benefit will be the 64MB cache. The second surprise will be that both Seagate and WD offer their free cloning program "Disk Wizard".

This system is feedback driven thru Solution and Kudo flags. It's the only means of knowing if you have been served.
Please click Accept as Solution, if your problem is solved. To say THANK YOU, press the "thumbs up symbol" to render a KUDO. You can render both Solution and KUDO..

Loaner: Envy Omen Windows 10 Home 64 4th Gen Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-4720HQ + NVIDIA GeForce GTX 960M 2GB Discrete Graphics (8GB memory) 128GB SSD
Loaner: HP ENVY 8 5002 Tablet
HP Envy 8 5010 Tablet
(2) HP DV7t i7 3160QM 2.3Ghz 8GB
HP m9200t E8400,Win7 Pro, 4GB RAM, ASUS 550Ti 2GB, Rosewill 630W. 1T HD
Custom Asus P8Z87D, I7-4770k, 16GB RAM, WIN7 Pro 64bit, EVGA GTX670 2GB, 500GB HD SSD, Rosewill Blackhawk case and OCZ 750W.
Printer -- HP OfficeJet Pro 8620
† The opinions expressed above are the personal opinions of the authors, not of HP. By using this site, you accept the Terms of Use and Rules of Participation