If you look at the settings in the embedded webserver you'll probably see that the tray 2 paper type is set incorrectly. Most people would have tried to set to plain letter.
If tray 2 is set correctly, and the printer is still asking for paper in tray 1 then your program is probably specifying that tray when you try to print.
If my post resolves your issue please click the accepted as solution button under it.
To thank a Tech for a post click the thumbs up button under the post.
You can even click both buttons. . .