@tessie65
Check whether the paper is within the Weight limits for "card" paper.
Printer Specifications for HP ENVY 4500, DeskJet 3540 Printers
Section Paper Handling
Paper tray capacities
What else?
The illustration you provided seems to show an embossed finish on the paper.
Even assuming the weight of the paper is supported, embossed finish will likely fail to print, get stuck, or provide odd results.
What else?
The Media list to which I have access (basic tech specs) does not include an alternate to the standard paper types.
Media Types | Paper (plain, inkjet, photo), envelopes, cards, HP premium media, iron-on transfers, borderless media |
IF your paper is not over the weight limit for Card paper,
IF your printer software shows a list of types that includes Brochure matte, try that paper type.
Observations
Index card paper is generally a lighter weight class (ISO standard for Index paper)
Index paper lacks an embossed (rough / uneven) finish.
Printer Home Page - References and Resources – Learn about your Printer - Solve Problems
“Things that are your printer”
NOTE: Content depends on device type and Operating System
Categories: Alerts, Access to the Print and Scan Doctor (Windows), Warranty Check, HP Drivers / Software / Firmware Updates, How-to Videos, Bulletins/Notices, Lots of How-to Documents, Troubleshooting, User Guides / Manuals, Product Information (Specifications), more
When the website support page opens, Select (as available) a Category > Topic > Subtopic
HP ENVY 4500 e-All-in-One Printer series
Thank you for participating in our HP Community.
We are a volunteer community workforce dedicated to supporting HP technology
Click Thumbs Up to say Thank You for the help.
If the answer helped resolve your issue, Click "Accept as Solution" .
Dragon-Fur